Making the grade: Crucial factors in assessing jade’s value

December 5, 2018

By Samuel Michael Dilts, Laura Acosta Vidales, and Andrew Loo

Photo ©[1]
Photo ©

Gemstones go through a series of processes—from the standard cutting and polishing to enhancement treatments—that transform the rough material into beautiful finished pieces to satisfy all types of customers. Jade is no exception to this. For centuries, producers have treated lower-quality jade to improve its marketability. This practice is still common today, and is accepted in the trade if full disclosure is respected, avoiding any kind of misrepresentation.

Enhancement treatments in jade seek to improve the stone’s colour, transparency, or stability. Even in the case of nephrite jade—which is seldom treated, as its structure rarely allows for dyes or resins—heat treatments may be used to improve the colour.

The main concern with all these treatments resides in the difficulty of their detection, as they rarely change the specimens’ refractive index (RI), specific gravity (SG), or hardness, which are the main tools most appraisers and jewellers rely on to identify a gemstone. The most reliable method to detect enhancements for both nephrite and jadeite jade is the use of fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectrometry and specialized lab equipment. For this reason, buyers in every stage of the value chain should require their suppliers to provide gemmological reports and certificates to validate the type and origin of traded pieces. (For more on jadeite treatments and identification, see “Judging jade: How to identify Type A, B, and C jadeite,” in the December 2018[2] issue of Jewellery Business.)

Another crucial factor for the jade trade is grading, which evaluates the quality of a piece regardless of its type or treatment status. As jade has been prominently marketed in Asia, Western markets have struggled to agree on a standardized process to grade the material. However, it is crucial to develop a clear system that allows transparent communication between buyers and sellers from anywhere in the world.

Gemstone grading aims to evaluate the different factors comprising a stone’s beauty. The effort to quantify a concept as subjective as beauty might seem impossible; however, with every gemstone, the main quality factors that contribute to a piece’s appeal are colour, transparency, cut, and clarity. In the case of jade, another factor is included: texture. A detailed description of how these factors are graded and their effect on a gem’s price would make a book unto itself. However, in this article, we would like to present a brief overview of the traits measured and treatments available in each category.

Grading evaluates the quality of a jade piece regardless of type or treatment. Photos courtesy New Sun Jade[3]
Grading evaluates the quality of a jade piece regardless of type or treatment.
Photos courtesy New Sun Jade

In gemstone grading, colour is the most important factor determining a gem’s attractiveness and marketability. In gemmological terms, colour is usually divided into three components:

Jade is mainly known for its green variety. However, both nephrite and jadeite are available in other hues. For example, jadeite can be lavender, yellow, black, white, red, orange, blue, grey, or even colourless, while nephrite can be found in white, grey, black, yellow, and brown. Both usually present unevenly distributed colouration, which make uniform vivid and medium-tone hues the most valuable ones, with pure green being the preferred colour.

The most common treatments impacting jade colour are bleaching and dyeing in jadeite and low-heat processing in nephrite. These treatments are not very reliable, and in some cases, they can bring out undesirable colours. The main concern with colour-treated pieces is the process compromises the stability and can be considered impermanent.

The impact on value of the jade piece here is twofold. The treatment can enhance value if the resulting colour is desirable in the market. However, a certified analysis of the piece can lower the value of the treated jade due to the aforementioned loss of stability and therefore lifespan.

Jade's colour, transparency, texture, cut, and clarity must all be considered when determining a piece's value.[4]
Jade’s colour, transparency, texture, cut, and clarity must all be considered when determining a piece’s value.

Transparency and texture
Chinese systems of jadeite evaluation measure ‘Zhong,’ or transparency and texture, to grade the quality of gem pieces. (See the second edition of R. Wise’s Secrets of the Gem Trade, published by Brunswick House Press in 2016.) These factors are closely related to the composition of jade stones, which are comprised of different microcrystals with varying degrees of uniformity. The finest specimens are those where these tiny crystals are evenly distributed, creating a smooth and soft look.

Jade transparency ranges from translucent to opaque. Neither jadeite nor nephrite can be fully transparent. However, the most desirable pieces present a high translucency that gives them a glass-like appearance. Jade texture refers to the smoothness and visual texture of the stone’s grain.

Wax coating to improve jade texture is a standard process observed in most A-grade pieces. It is widely accepted and has no impact on value. The main treatment to enhance lower-quality pieces is polymer resin impregnation, which is common practice in Asian markets and very difficult to detect if undisclosed. If unsure, buyers should either request a gemmological report or refer the pieces for further examination.

Jade is usually cut into cabochons or carved into ornamental pieces. The quality of the cut is measured by the lustre achieved during the polishing process. Fine jadeite specimens can achieve a high glass lustre, which gives them the appearance of being wet and is enhanced by the transparency of fine material. Being softer than jadeite, nephrite jade undergoes less polishing and may present a resin or waxy lustre. Polymer impregnation can alter the polished look of finished pieces.

Jade is mainly known for its green variety, but both jadeite and nephrite can be found in other colours, such as white, yellow, black, brown, and lavender.[5]
Jade is mainly known for its green variety, but both jadeite and nephrite can be found in other colours, such as white, yellow, black, brown, and lavender.

The last quality factor measured in jade is its clarity, which is determined by the absence of visible defects such as spotting, cottony or silky inclusions, and fractures. These characteristics influence the value of more high-quality transparent gems. However, inclusions can increase the value of nephrite if the presence of silk creates chatoyancy, giving rise to the most sought-after cat’s eye jade. Clarity enhancement is usually achieved with the same polymer impregnation process to deal with surface-reaching fractures, which would otherwise compromise the stone’s durability.

As noted previously, nephrite is seldom treated because its microscopic, nonporous, oil- and acid-resistant, ‘fabric-like’ structure rarely allows for dyes or resins. Heat treatments may be used; however, the comparative availability of nephrite over the rarer jadeite does not command manipulation for it to be placed in the market as a valuable gemstone. Its identity is almost always natural. Also, some heat treatments can actually reduce the stability of the mineral, as with tanzanite.

The variables of value
This article offers a brief overview of the five key characteristics of jade consumers consider when purchasing either jadeite or nephrite. As with all gemstones, personal preference and purchasing agenda influence how value is ascribed to jade items. The authors wish to emphasize the fact the jade value chain (JVC) is complex, and that to best understand all the variables influencing industry assessment of jade from mine to retail, a more detailed presentation is required. One such presentation is currently being prepared.

These authors have designed a system that works to penetrate the predominantly clandestine jade business model in Asia for the benefit of global consumers of this ancient gemstone. For more on this system and on valuing jade, watch for a future issue of Jewellery Business.

[6]Samuel Michael Dilts, B.Sc., is a graduate in molecular medicine from the Australian National University, a sculptor, and an industrial designer. He is the founder of New Sun Jade of Vancouver and BC Jade of Hong Kong. Dilts is the creator of several patented and trademarked jade products designed to advance the sustainability of the jade value chain (JVC) for North American industry professionals. He can be reached via e-mail at

[7]Laura Acosta Vidales, GIA GG, AJP, holds a B.Sc. in economics from Anuhuac University and an M.Sc. in finance from the London School of Business and Finance. She graduated from the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) in 2011, defines herself as a gem enthusiast, and has been studying and collecting gems for as long as she can remember. Currently, Vidales works as an independent gemmologist in Mexico, identifying and appraising pieces. She can be reached via e-mail at

[8]Andrew Loo holds a B.A. from Windsor University as well as a post-graduate degree in geology from Peking University. He is a Fellow of the Gemmological Association of Great Britain (Gem-A) and has been a gemstone educator for nearly two decades, having joined the gemstone laboratories in Hong Kong and Antwerp. Loo currently works as a gemmologist, with a private client base of collectors, jewellery retailers, auction houses, and gemmological associations. He can be reached via e-mail at

  1. [Image]:
  2. December 2018:
  3. [Image]:
  4. [Image]:
  5. [Image]:
  6. [Image]:
  7. [Image]:
  8. [Image]:

Source URL: